Entry 003 ยท Art
Limited Edition Prints: What Your Certificate of Authenticity Must Say When You Sell Online
California and New York require written disclosures for prints sold into those states. The required certificate fields, what the edition number warrants, and how to run an honest numbered edition on Shopify.
You sell prints online, and a collector asks what "12/50" actually promises. Is that the whole run? Are there artist's proofs on top? Will the image turn up again in a bigger edition next year? Several US states answer this in law. California and New York have the most detailed rules on what a print seller must disclose in writing, and both apply to sales made "into or from" the state, so they can reach a seller who ships there from anywhere. This guide works through those two.
This is general information, not legal advice. The statutes are linked below; check with a lawyer about your own situation.
Who these laws cover
California's fine print law (Civil Code ยงยง1740โ1745.5) covers "fine art multiples": prints, photographs, sculpture casts and similar objects "produced in more than one copy" (ยง1740(a)). A "fine print" includes engraving, etching, woodcut, lithography and serigraphy, and "multiples produced or developed from photographic negatives". It applies to a multiple "offered for sale or sold at wholesale or retail for one hundred dollars ($100) or more, exclusive of any frame" (ยง1741).
The duties fall on an "art dealer", defined in ยง1740(g) as "a person who is in the business of dealing, exclusively or nonexclusively, in the fine art multiples to which this title is applicable, or a person who by his or her occupation holds himself or herself out as having knowledge or skill peculiar to these works". Artists selling their own work are addressed separately in ยง1742(e): "Whenever an artist sells or consigns a multiple of his or her own creation or conception, the artist shall disclose the information required by Section 1744, but an artist shall not otherwise be regarded as an art dealer."
New York's Arts and Cultural Affairs Law, Article 15, uses the term "art merchant" and the same "in, into or from this state" wording. Its statutory notice describes disclosure for "multiples of prints and photographs when sold for more than one hundred dollars ($100) each, exclusive of any frame" (ยง15.01). Note the difference: $100 or more in California, more than $100 in New York. How the remedies in each state apply to a self-selling artist is a question for a lawyer.
When the certificate is due, and what that means for a product page
Under ยง1742(a) the certificate must be furnished on request or "in any event prior to a sale". If a buyer asks, it goes to them before they pay or order. If they pay before delivery, which is every online order, it must be supplied "at the time of or prior to delivery". New York's ยง15.01(1) uses the same timing.
Both states also regulate "a catalogue, prospectus, flyer, or other written material or advertisement" that "solicits a direct sale, by inviting transmittal of payment for a specific multiple" (ยง1742(b), ยง15.01(2)). Such material must show the required details "in close physical proximity" to where the print is described, or carry a statutory notice passage and then supply the details by delivery. The California passage also tells buyers they may return the print within 30 days for a refund for reasons related to that information. Whether a product page with an Add to cart button counts as such material is a fair question to put to counsel. The cautious approach is to put the details next to the listing.
The disclosure checklist
ยง1744(a) lists what the certificate must contain. Here it is in plain terms, usable both on a product page and on the certificate itself:
| Field | What to state |
|---|---|
| 1. Artist | The name of the artist. |
| 2. Signature | Whether the print was signed by the artist by hand. If not, where the name on it comes from (signed in the plate, stamped, estate-stamped, other). |
| 3. Medium or process | Etching, lithograph, screenprint, giclรฉe/inkjet, a named photographic process. If no trade term fits, a brief, clear description. |
| 4. Reproduction | Whether it is a photomechanical or photographic reproduction of an image made in another medium (e.g. a print of a painting), and both mediums. |
| 5. Written approval | If (4) applies and the print is unsigned: whether the artist authorized or approved the edition in writing. |
| 6โ7. Deceased / posthumous | Whether the artist was dead when the master was made, or when the print was produced from it. |
| 8. Prior editions | Whether the master produced an earlier limited edition, and the total count, proofs included, of those other editions. |
| 9. Year | The year, or approximate year, the print was produced. |
| 10. Limited edition | Whether it is offered as a limited edition and, if so: the maximum signed/numbered impressions, the maximum unsigned/unnumbered impressions, the maximum proofs outside the edition, and the total edition size. |
| 11. Master | Whether the master has been destroyed, effaced, altered, defaced or cancelled after this edition. |
Every California certificate must also carry this sentence, word for word (ยง1740(j)): "This is to certify that all information and the statements contained herein are true and correct." Older works need fewer fields (ยง1744(c)โ(e)), but a print you make today needs them all, and where a field does not apply the statute expects you to say so.
Why the numbers matter
The information on a certificate creates express warranties, even without the words "warrant" or "guarantee" (ยง1744.7). For limited editions printed after 1 January 1983, ยง1744(b) goes further: the stated edition size is "an express warranty that no additional multiples of the same image, including proofs, have been produced in this or in any other limited edition."
If the certificate is missing or the information is untrue, "except for harmless errors, such as typographical errors", the buyer can return the print and recover what they paid, with interest (ยง1745). For willful violations the amount is tripled. Claims must be brought within one year of discovery and no more than three years after the sale, and a court may award the prevailing buyer attorneys' and expert fees. Separately, ยง1745.5 allows injunctions and a civil penalty of up to $1,000 per violation, plus a surcharge of up to $1,000.
Setting edition size and proofs
Edition size itself is your call; the law only asks you to state it and stick to it. As an industry reference, the UK's Fine Art Trade Guild print standard sets a maximum edition of 1,950 and recommends keeping editions below 850 worldwide, and notes that most limited editions are signed and numbered in pencil. The Guild adds that the promise not to reproduce the image elsewhere "is not a legal requirement". In California, for limited editions printed after 1 January 1983, ยง1744(b) makes part of that promise a warranty: the stated size warrants that no additional multiples of the same image, proofs included, have been produced in this or any other limited edition.
The practical rule: decide how many artist's proofs (AP), printer's proofs (PP) and other proofs exist before you print, and write the number down. Under ยง1744(a)(10) the proof count is part of what you disclose, and under ยง1744(b) part of what you warrant.
Running a numbered edition on Shopify
- Cap sales at the edition size. Turn on inventory tracking, set the quantity to the number of impressions for sale, and leave "Continue selling when out of stock" off, so the store cannot sell impression N+1.
- Record which impression shipped. Where it helps, use one variant or one SKU per edition number, so each order shows exactly which print the buyer received.
- Keep the disclosure next to the item. Put the checklist fields in the product description, or in metafields your theme shows on the product page.
Making the certificate verifiable
A paper certificate can be copied and a PDF can be edited. VeriFined adds a record a buyer can check online. It sits alongside the statutory disclosure; it does not replace it.
- Numbered editions as a Series. Create a Series in the dashboard with the edition size, and each impression becomes its own product, numbered 1/N through N/N (see Series management). Put the checklist details in the series description so they are part of every impression's record.
- Shopify orders. With the Shopify app, each item in a paid order gets its own record, and when you fulfill the order the buyer receives a certificate with a QR code that opens a public verification page. The record holds the product title, variant, SKU, description and image from the order. Shopify orders don't carry an edition number automatically, which is another reason to use a variant or SKU per impression and to keep the disclosure in the product description.
- Ownership that follows the print. You can issue the buyer a one-time code to claim ownership, and on resale they can transfer it to the next owner. Each transfer is added to the print's history.
- Optional blockchain anchoring. You can turn on anchoring per product or series (it is off by default, including for Shopify orders). Anchored records are batched hourly into a Merkle tree on Solana, with a copy on IPFS, so anyone can check a record has not changed since it was anchored.
A copy-ready certificate template
- Artist: [name]
- Title: [title of the image]
- Medium / process: [e.g. archival pigment print (giclรฉe) on cotton rag paper]
- Reproduction: [e.g. "Photomechanical reproduction of an original oil painting" / "Original print, not a reproduction"]
- Signature: [signed and numbered by hand in pencil by the artist / unsigned; source of name]
- Year produced: [year]
- Edition: [n] of [N] signed and numbered; [x] unsigned/unnumbered; proofs: [a] AP, [p] PP; total edition size: [total]
- Prior editions from this master: [none / details]
- Master: [cancelled / destroyed / retained after this edition]
- "This is to certify that all information and the statements contained herein are true and correct."
- Signature and date of the seller; verification QR code
FAQ
Do these rules apply if I'm not in California or New York?
Both statutes cover sales "into or from" the state, and New York's also "in" it. If you ship prints at or above the price thresholds to buyers there, read the sections linked above and ask a lawyer how they apply to you. Other states have their own print disclosure laws too; Illinois, for example, has the Fine Prints Disclosure Act (815 ILCS 345). The details differ from state to state, so check each place you ship to.
Are open editions covered?
ยง1744(a)(10) asks "whether the edition is being offered as a limited edition", so the disclosure still applies to a print that isn't. Under ยง1742(d), describing an edition as "reproductions" removes the need for further detail, unless it is held out as signed, numbered or limited, in which case every detail is required.
Does a verifiable certificate replace the disclosure?
No. The statutes set what you must state. A verifiable record makes what you stated checkable later, including by the next owner.
For how this looks in practice, see our guide to certificates of authenticity for art (and the general guide), the artists use case, how resale buyers verify authenticity, and how to fight "item not as described" chargebacks.