← The Register

Entry 001 · Shopify

How to Fight "Item Not as Described" Chargebacks With Certificates of Authenticity

For handmade, art, jewelry and collectibles sellers: how "not as described" disputes work on Shopify, what evidence actually helps, and how to build it into every order.

By the VeriFined teamPublished September 28, 20268 min readRSS

If you sell one-of-a-kind or high-value pieces — handmade jewelry, original art, collectibles, luxury resale — the dispute you dread isn't "I never ordered this". It's "this isn't what was described" or "this isn't genuine". The buyer has the item, the bank has their complaint, and you have a few days to prove what you actually sold.

This guide explains how these disputes work under the card-network rules and in Shopify, what evidence is actually requested, and how to have that evidence ready for every order before a dispute ever arrives.

The Dispute Categories You're Dealing With

Card networks classify disputes by reason. The ones that matter for authenticity sellers:

  • Visa 13.3 — Not as Described or Defective Merchandise/Services. The item didn't match its description at the time of purchase, or the buyer disputes its quality. Before disputing, the cardholder generally has to try to resolve it with you and return (or attempt to return) the item. Source: Visa Core Rules.
  • Visa 13.4 — Counterfeit Merchandise. The buyer claims the item is fake. Visa requires the merchandise to have been identified as counterfeit by the IP owner, a government agency or a third-party expert — and the buyer doesn't have to return it.
  • Mastercard 4853 — Cardholder Dispute. Mastercard groups "not as described" and "counterfeit goods alleged to be authentic" under one code in its Chargeback Guide. For counterfeit claims, the cardholder's own statement and a description of the goods are enough; your response is documentation proving the goods were genuine.

Buyers typically have up to 120 days to raise these disputes (counted from the transaction or, in some cases, from delivery), so evidence from the day of sale needs to stay available for months.

In Shopify, both kinds usually appear as "Product unacceptable": the customer feels the product "was received but was defective, damaged, or not as described".

What Shopify and Visa Tell You to Submit

For a "Product unacceptable" chargeback, Shopify's help center recommends submitting:

  • The date and time you fulfilled the order
  • The billing information the customer used
  • Shipping and tracking information
  • Descriptions or pictures of the products from your store that prove they were as described
  • Evidence that the customer didn't try to return the product, or that you offered a replacement

Visa's dispute management guidelines for merchants add two useful points for 13.3: address each point the cardholder makes, and where needed, get a neutral third-party opinion to corroborate your claim. For 13.4 they are blunt: show the merchandise was authentic, with "specific information and invoices to refute the cardholder's claims".

The Deadline Problem

Shopify says the evidence due date varies from 7 to 21 days after the chargeback is filed, and that after the deadline "you can't submit any further evidence. There are no exceptions to this." The decision itself can take up to 75 days after you submit.

That is why evidence assembled after the fact is weak twice over: it's slow to collect, and it looks exactly like what it is — something produced once there was a dispute. The strongest evidence was created at the time of the sale and shared with the buyer then.

What a Good Certificate Proves (and What It Doesn't)

A certificate of authenticity is not a magic dispute-winner, and no honest vendor should tell you it is. Banks weigh all the evidence. But a well-made certificate covers the exact gap in "not as described" and counterfeit claims: what, precisely, did you sell?

A certificate that helps in a dispute:

  • Is specific to the unit — a unique certificate number, the product name, variant (metal, size, colour), SKU and an image, not a generic "this product is genuine" card.
  • Was issued at the time of the sale, with a date, to the named buyer.
  • Was delivered to the buyer — emailed with the order, so there's a record they received the description with the goods.
  • Can be checked independently — a QR code or link to a public page, so the bank or a third-party expert can confirm it's the certificate you issued, not one mocked up later.
  • Has a tamper-evident history — ideally a timeline of order, payment and fulfilment events that can't be edited after the fact.

What it doesn't prove: that the item is genuine in an absolute sense. A certificate is your statement, made verifiable. For high-value pieces, pair it with independent evidence — a gemological report for stones, an expert's opinion for art, hallmarks for precious metals. (We cover these in how resale buyers verify authenticity.)

Prevention Beats Representment

Both Visa and Mastercard expect the buyer to contact you before a "not as described" dispute. Make that conversation easy and well-documented:

  1. Describe honestly and precisely. Materials, dimensions, condition, and anything handmade-specific ("small variations are expected"). Visa's guidance says descriptions should be "accurate, complete, and not misleading". In the US, the FTC's Jewelry Guides even define when you may call a piece "handmade".
  2. Photograph what you ship, not just the listing photo — especially for one-offs and resale items.
  3. Send the certificate with the order so the buyer can check authenticity themselves the day it arrives, instead of wondering.
  4. Publish a clear returns path. Visa counts an attempted return as made if the merchant "did not provide clear instructions on how to return" — so ambiguity works against you.
  5. Keep every message. The customer conversation is evidence too.

How Our Shopify App Handles It

Our Shopify app builds the certificate side of this into your normal workflow. When an order is placed, each unit gets its own digital record; when you mark the order fulfilled, the app generates a PDF certificate of authenticity for each item — certificate number, product name, image, variant options, buyer, date and a QR code — and emails it to the customer. The QR code opens a public verification page with the product's chain of custody (order placed, payment confirmed, fulfilled with tracking), and you can choose to anchor those records on the Solana blockchain so they can't be altered later.

When a dispute comes in, you have a dated certificate the buyer received, a public link the bank can open, and a timeline to attach to your Shopify response. For setup, see How to Add Certificates of Authenticity to Your Shopify Store or our guides for jewelry and art.

Card-network rules and Shopify's process change over time; the details above reflect the Visa Core Rules (April 2026 edition), the Mastercard Chargeback Guide (May 2026) and Shopify's help center as of September 2026. This is general information, not legal advice.

Give every order a certificate buyers can check.
Install the Shopify app and every fulfilled order gets a certificate with a public verify page. Blockchain anchoring is optional, runs in hourly batches and is off by default.
Install VeriFined